954-539-5678Free audit
Menu

Managed IT · Consulting

Hire a consultant for a project. Hire a provider for the years after it.

A consultant is paid to finish something. A managed provider is paid to keep things running. Mixing up the two is how small businesses overpay.

Consultants finish projects, then leave

Managed providers bill per user, monthly

Watch for advice that creates work

Get your free Technology Health Assessment

30 minutes of data collection, your report the next day, yours to keep with no obligation. Or pick a time on the calendar below. Or call 954-539-5678.

Two different jobs

When a small business overpays for IT help, it is usually because it hired the right kind of person for the wrong kind of job. An IT consultant is hired to finish something: move the file server to the cloud, wire the new office, clean up after a security scare, choose an accounting system, tell you whether your current setup makes sense. There is a start, an end and a deliverable. A managed service provider (MSP) is hired to keep things running with no end date: the help desk, updates, backups, security tools, new starters and leavers, the vendor calls, the thousand small things that break on an ordinary Wednesday.

That is the whole distinction, and it is a pretty big deal, because the two are paid differently and so they are motivated differently. If what you need has a finish line, you want a consultant, or a provider willing to work as one for that project. If what you need is the same work every month, you want a managed provider. Most growing businesses need both at different times.

When a consultant is the right hire

Bring in a consultant when the job is bigger or rarer than whoever runs your IT day to day can reasonably handle. Typical examples:

  • Moving off an old on-site server to Microsoft 365, SharePoint or Google Workspace.
  • Setting up a new or second office: cabling, network, phones, printers, access.
  • A security cleanup after a breach, a failed insurance questionnaire or a scary audit.
  • Choosing or connecting a line-of-business system, such as a CRM, ERP or practice management package.
  • A second opinion on your current provider, your budget or your next three years of spending.

A good consultant will scope the work in writing, give you a fixed price or a capped estimate, hand over documentation when they finish, and then go away. That last part is not a flaw. It is what you paid for.

When you need a managed provider

Once you have more than a handful of people, someone has to answer the “my Outlook is frozen” call, approve the updates, watch the backups, remove the person who left on Friday, and renew the domain before it lapses. A consultant can do any one of those things, but paying project rates for routine work every week gets expensive and, in my experience, things fall between the visits. That ongoing layer is what a managed provider is for. It is the old break-fix versus managed IT question, and for most offices past ten or so people the answer is managed.

How the pricing differs

Consultants usually bill one of three ways: by the hour, by a fixed project fee, or by a monthly retainer for a set number of advisory hours (the fractional CIO model, which we cover in our piece on fractional CIOs). Managed providers almost always bill per user or per device per month, with the price driven by how many people, locations and systems you have and how much support you need. That is how we price our managed IT too, and our guide to what managed IT costs walks through the drivers.

The incentives fall out of the billing. An hourly consultant earns more when a project takes longer. A per-user provider earns more when things don’t break, because a quiet month costs them less labor. Neither model is virtuous on its own. Each needs a check: a fixed scope or a cap for the consultant, and clear response times and reporting for the provider.

The conflict nobody mentions

Here is my firm opinion, and you can weigh it knowing that we run managed IT ourselves. A consultant who finishes your assessment with a recommendation that you hire them to run your IT forever is selling the second thing. The assessment was the sales call.

That does not make the recommendation wrong. Sometimes the honest answer to “what should we do?” really is “you need ongoing help, and we provide it”. The problem is that you can’t tell whether the advice is shaped by your needs or by their pipeline. So separate the two questions. Ask for the findings and the recommended next steps in writing, as a document you own outright, before any proposal for ongoing work. Then show that document to someone else, or at least sleep on it. Good advice survives a second reader.

The same caution runs the other way. A managed provider that quotes a large “project” every time something needs attention is a consultant wearing a monthly contract. Your managed services agreement should say plainly what is included and what counts as a project.

Want an independent picture first? Our free Technology Health Assessment is about 30 minutes of data collection. The next day you get a plain-language report rating IT operations, cybersecurity, applications, integration, automation, AI opportunities, technology spending and business continuity, with a short list of next steps in order. It is yours to keep, with no obligation, and you are free to hand it to someone else to act on. Book your assessment.

A simple way to decide

  1. Write down the problem in one sentence. If it has a finish line (“move to SharePoint by March”), it is a project.
  2. If it is a project, get a written scope, a fixed fee or a capped estimate, and a list of the documentation you will receive at the end.
  3. If the problem is “things keep breaking” or “nobody owns this”, it is ongoing work. Get per-user pricing, response times in writing and a monthly report.
  4. If one firm offers both, take the project first and judge them on it before signing anything long-term.

Book it now

Pick a time for your 30 minutes

Choose a slot that suits you. We’ll confirm by email, collect the data with you on the call, and send your report the next day. It’s free, and the report is yours to keep with no obligation.

Prefer to talk first? Call 954-539-5678, or send the form and we’ll contact you.

Questions we hear

Can one company be both my IT consultant and my managed provider?

Yes, and plenty are. Just keep the two engagements separate on paper: the project with its own scope and price, the ongoing service with its own agreement. That way you can end one without losing the other.

Is an IT consultant cheaper than a managed provider?

For a single project, usually. For ongoing support, rarely, because routine work billed by the hour adds up fast and gets done later than it should. Compare the cost of a full year, not one invoice.

Do I still need a consultant if I already have a managed provider?

Sometimes. A second opinion on a big decision, a specialist system or a security review can be worth paying for even when your provider is good. A provider that objects to you getting one is telling you something.

Related services

Want to know where your business stands?

Pick a time for my free assessmentCall 954-539-5678